Cargo e-bikes are quickly becoming the car replacement of choice for families, commuters, and delivery riders. Two brands dominate very different ends of the cargo market: Rad Power Bikes, the budget-friendly giant, and Xtracycle, the premium pioneer.
In this guide, we’ll put them head-to-head to help you decide: Rad Power or Xtracycle?
Overview
- Rad Power Bikes – Direct-to-consumer e-bike company founded in Seattle, best known for the RadWagon 5 cargo e-bike. Affordable, widely available, and hugely popular with first-time cargo bike buyers. Read our Rad Power Review
- Xtracycle – Cargo bike pioneer with deep roots in the category. Premium pricing, Bosch motors, and family-focused designs. The choice for serious daily haulers. Read our Xtracycle Review
Price Comparison
- Rad Power RadWagon 5
- MSRP: ~$1,999
- Hub-motor powered, mechanical disc brakes, basic cargo system
- Direct-to-consumer sales model keeps prices low
- Xtracycle Swoop / RFA / Stoker
- MSRP: ~$4,000–$6,000+
- Bosch mid-drive motors, hydraulic brakes, dual battery options
- Sold through premium dealers and direct from brand
Takeaway: Rad Power is a fraction of the cost of Xtracycle. But you’re trading lower cost for lower specs.
Motor and Performance
- Rad Power:
- Rear hub motor (750W peak, 5-level pedal assist + throttle)
- Great for flat to moderate hills, struggles under heavy load
- Feels more “moped-like”
- Xtracycle:
- Bosch Cargo Line or Performance Line mid-drive
- Smooth torque sensing = natural pedaling feel
- Climbs hills better, especially with passengers or groceries
Takeaway: If you live in a hilly city, Xtracycle is hands-down better. Rad works fine in flatter areas.
Battery & Range
- Rad Power:
- 672Wh battery, ~25–45 miles per charge
- Single battery only
- Xtracycle:
- 500Wh stock, expandable to 1000Wh (dual)
- ~35–70 miles per charge depending on load and terrain
Takeaway: Rad has decent range for its price, but Xtracycle wins for endurance and dual battery flexibility.
Cargo Capacity
- RadWagon 5:
- Rated up to 350 lbs
- Solid integrated rack, works with Rad accessories
- Popular with budget-conscious families
- Xtracycle:
- Rated up to 400 lbs (some models exceed this)
- Extensive ecosystem: Hooptie rails, running boards, kid seats, huge panniers
- Designed from the ground up as a true family hauler
Takeaway: Both can haul kids and groceries, but Xtracycle feels like a minivan replacement, while Rad is more of a budget wagon.
Build Quality & Components
- Rad Power:
- Mechanical disc brakes (budget-friendly but less stopping power)
- Entry-level drivetrain
- Sturdy frame but heavier feel
- Xtracycle:
- Hydraulic disc brakes
- Bosch drivetrain integration
- Higher-end components for long-term durability
Takeaway: Xtracycle clearly wins on build quality. Rad Power wins on affordability.
Accessibility & Ride Feel
- Rad Power:
- Throttle helps beginners feel confident
- Easy entry point for first-time e-bike buyers
- More like a casual cruiser with cargo capability
- Xtracycle:
- Requires pedaling (Bosch = no throttle)
- Feels natural, stable, and confidence-inspiring under heavy load
- More “bike-like” vs. Rad’s “moped-like” feel
Takeaway: Rad is better for beginners or riders who like throttle; Xtracycle for those who want a true bicycle experience.
Support & Service
- Rad Power:
- Online sales with limited service network
- Growing list of service partners, but DIY often required
- Xtracycle:
- Sold through premium bike shops
- Bosch systems = global service availability
- Higher upfront cost, but better long-term support
Takeaway: Rad is improving, but Xtracycle has the edge in reliability and service.
Who Should Buy Each?
Rad Power is best for:
- Families on a budget
- Riders in flat to moderate terrain
- First-time cargo e-bike buyers
- People who want throttle control
Xtracycle is best for:
- Families replacing a second car
- Riders in hilly terrain
- Those hauling heavy loads daily
- Long-term investment buyers
Pros and Cons Side by Side
Rad Power Pros
- Very affordable
- Widely available
- Easy to ride with throttle
- Good entry into cargo bikes
Rad Power Cons
- Weaker on hills
- Budget components
- Limited accessory ecosystem compared to Xtracycle
Xtracycle Pros
- Premium Bosch mid-drives
- Long history in cargo bike design
- Huge accessory range for families
- High durability and safety
Xtracycle Cons
- Expensive ($4K–$6K+)
- Heavy and large to store
- No throttle (pedal assist only)
Bottom Line: Rad vs. Xtracycle
This choice comes down to budget vs. premium:
- If you want an affordable cargo e-bike for hauling kids and groceries around town, the RadWagon 5 is an incredible deal. It gets the job done for under $2,000.
- If you’re looking for a true car replacement, with the best motors, reliability, and family accessories, Xtracycle is worth the higher price.
–> Compare more cargo options: Best Cargo E-Bikes
Related Content:
- Tern Bicycles Review
- Best Cargo E-Bikes
- Yuba Bikes Review
- Best Commuter Bikes Guide
- Best Budget E-Bike Brands Guide
Why Trust This Guide?
Jeffrey South is the founder of Best Bike Brands. With over 30 years in the cycling world as a shop owner, mechanic, and industry insider, he now shares reviews, guides, and insights to help riders choose the best bikes and gear with confidence.
